Where we make the freshest homemade pizza in town and more.....

Come take a walk into Old Lyme Connecticut's best pizza restaurant to experience the best pizza our shore has to offer. From fresh sea-foods to local attractions or just a walk on the beach....

But Wait.... What's that.... Pizza!!!

Here at Pizza Plus we make our mouthwatering pizza daily. Come witness John and Chris put all of their effort into making their dough from scratch. While Jorge adds the extra kick that makes our sauce amazing. C.J., Despina or Yota are there daily to cut fresh peppers, onions, and toppings to add to any pizza you want. Whether you want to create your own, have a nibble at one of our gourmet pizzas or indulge in a hot oven grinder, Pizza Plus offers anything your taste buds desire!

All of the ingredients used at Pizza Plus are bought and traded through local markets and farmers. All of our peppers, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, garlic and cheeses are cut fresh daily simply for your enjoyment. When you step into our cozy restaurant you are able to experience how we prepare your food while standing at our counter. All of the Pizza Plus employees take our passion for food serious so we make sure you have a great experience whether you choose to dine inside, outside or simply take your food home to eat.

Not sure what to get? Try our world famous Philly Steak and Cheese subs. Our thinly shredded steak with melted hot cheese on a crispy toasted sub with a hint of a secret sauce will keep you begging for more.

Pizza Plus's daily purchases include fresh grinders subs from Michele's Family Bakery located in West Haven Ct, shredded blends of Brand 1950 127 cheddar and mozzarella cheeses for our pizzas and deli and produce products provided from CityLine Distributions.

Here at Pizza Plus we never buy our lasagnas all ready made. We take our time making it from scratch by adding layers if fresh pasta, ground beef, fresh tomatoes sauce, and ricotta cheese.

Pizza Plus is proud to have Jorge aboard. During the springtime our cook Jorge plants seeds in his garden so by the summer his harvests produce freshly grown lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, peppers, onions, and herbs in which he donates to Pizza Plus who then sells to you. We are proud to support our local growers who make it possible to serve you the freshest ingredients.

We are also known for our homemade house dressing. We use fresh chopped garlic, oregano, extra virgin olive oil, red Italian style vinegar, fresh ground pepper, salt,  homegrown basil, and a few dashes of other ingredients that I just can't tell you! 

Our company was established in 2001 located on 284 Shore Road across the street from the entrance of Sound View Beach on Hartford Ave. John is the proud owner of Pizza Plus who took his 20 years of experience and knowledge to a new height by opened a family owned and operated business. He works along side his twin brother Chris, wife Litza and two daughters Despina and Yota, his sister in law Janine, longtime friend Jorge and creative director C.J.

Pizza Plus is located off of exit 71 coming from 95 North and exit 70 from 95 South. Feel free to call us for directions, questions or comments. We are open 7 days a week. Monday through Saturday from 11am to 9pm and Sundays from 11am to 8 pm. Pizza plus is also open all year round. Yes... we are open all season. Spring, summer, fall and winter.

We can't wait to meet you and for our guest that keep coming, we will see you when you get here! Pizza Plus is now proud to announce that the link below allows you to link to facebook and write a comment about our services. Feel free to leave us any comments or even a quick hello on our facebook page. We can't wait to hear what you have to say.

Pizza Plus
284 Shore Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371
(860) 434- 3282
We are also on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Pizza-Plus/186624598085062
Mondays- Saturdays: 11am to 9pm
Sundays: 11am to 8pm
Open all year round :)